Why Should I Use a Mohel for My Son’s Circumcision?

If you're planning a circumcision for your newborn son, you may be wondering whether to have it performed
in the hospital, at a doctor's office, or by a mohel.
For many parents, the word mohel immediately brings to mind a traditional Jewish bris. But performing the bris ceremony is only part of what an experienced mohel does. A mohel is a practitioner who specializes specifically in circumcision, and families may choose a mohel because of that specialized experience, the personal attention, the ability to have the circumcision performed at home, and the direct follow-up available afterward.
So, why use a mohel for circumcision instead of simply having it done at the hospital?
There isn't one answer that's right for every family. But there are some important differences worth understanding before choosing who will perform your son's circumcision.
1. A Mohel Specializes in Circumcision
Perhaps the most important reason parents choose a mohel is specialization.
A physician who performs newborn circumcisions may also spend his or her time delivering babies, treating illnesses, performing other procedures, or providing general medical care. For an experienced mohel, circumcision is the primary procedure he performs.
That means a mohel may have extensive experience not only performing circumcisions, but also examining babies beforehand, working with different anatomy, helping parents prepare, providing aftercare, and following the healing process afterward.
I've been performing circumcisions for more than 15 years. My formal training began at the London School of Circumcision, followed by more than three years of hands-on apprenticeship and training in Israel. Since then, I have performed circumcisions for families from a wide variety of backgrounds and in many different settings.
When choosing anyone to circumcise your baby—mohel or physician—I recommend asking a simple question:
How often do you actually perform circumcisions?
The title of the practitioner matters, but so does his or her specific experience with the procedure you're choosing for your son.
2. Mohel Circumcision Is Usually Very Quick
One of the things that surprises parents most is how quickly the actual circumcision can be performed.
With the technique I use, the circumcision itself generally takes well under one minute. In many cases, the actual procedure is approximately 30 seconds.
The appointment, of course, takes longer. I want time beforehand to examine the baby, prepare carefully and answer the parents' questions. Afterward, we make sure the baby is comfortable and review exactly what the parents should expect during healing.
But the procedure itself is very brief.
I use a traditional Mogen shield, which protects the glans during the circumcision and allows the procedure to be performed efficiently. It is removed immediately as part of the procedure and does not remain attached to the baby afterward.
For parents who are nervous about how their baby will handle the circumcision, the brevity of the actual procedure is often reassuring.
3. A Mohel Can Perform the Circumcision at Home
Another major reason families choose a mohel is the ability to have a newborn circumcision at home.
A circumcision doesn't necessarily require bringing your newborn back into a hospital or medical office.
For many of the families I work with, I come directly to their home. The baby remains in a familiar environment, the parents can stay nearby, and there is no waiting room or additional trip with a newborn.
For families who prefer another setting, other arrangements may also be available.
Home circumcision can be particularly appealing after a home birth or birthing-center birth, but hospital-birth families choose it as well. Some parents simply appreciate being able to handle the circumcision privately and comfortably at home.
4. You Choose the Person Who Will Circumcise Your Baby
When you arrange your son's circumcision directly with a mohel, you know exactly who will be performing it.
You can speak with the mohel before scheduling. You can ask about his training, how long he has been practicing, what circumcision technique he uses, what he does for comfort, and what happens if you have questions afterward.
That's important.
Parents understandably spend time researching car seats, pediatricians, bottles and everything else connected to a new baby. Choosing the person who will perform your son's circumcision deserves at least the same opportunity to ask questions.
I encourage parents to speak with me before making their decision. I would much rather have a parent ask ten questions beforehand than feel uncertain about something on the day of the circumcision.
5. Parents Can Stay With Their Baby
Some parents are uncomfortable with the idea of their newborn being taken away for circumcision.
With a private circumcision, that generally isn't necessary.
Parents can usually remain present if they would like to. You can see where your baby is and what is happening, and you can hold, comfort and feed him immediately afterward.
Some parents want to watch everything. Others would rather be nearby without actually watching the procedure. And some would prefer to step out for those few moments.
All of those reactions are completely normal.
The important thing is that parents can choose what makes them most comfortable.
6. The Mohel Is Available After the Circumcision
The circumcision itself may take less than a minute.
My responsibility to the baby doesn't end when that minute is over.
Parents receive instructions explaining how to care for the circumcision, what normal healing looks like and what should prompt a phone call.
More importantly, parents have direct access to me afterward.
If you're unsure about something you're seeing, you can call or message me. Parents frequently send a picture and ask, “Does this look normal?”
If something needs to be seen in person, I can arrange to examine the baby.
That continuity can be especially valuable for first-time parents. Instead of wondering whether something is normal or trying to explain the procedure to someone who wasn't there, you can contact the person who actually performed your son's circumcision.
7. A Mohel Isn't Only for a Traditional Bris
A common question is:
Do I need to be religious to use a mohel?
No.
A mohel is most closely associated with bris milah, the traditional Jewish circumcision performed on the eighth day when appropriate. I regularly perform traditional brissim for families who want the complete religious ceremony.
But not every family is looking for exactly the same thing.
I work with Jewish families across a wide range of observance, interfaith families, and families seeking circumcision for cultural or personal reasons.
Some families want a traditional bris with family and friends. Some want a very small bris at home. Others are primarily looking for an experienced circumcision practitioner and don't want an elaborate ceremony.
The experience can be tailored to the family.
8. What About Pain During a Mohel Circumcision?
This is one of the first questions parents ask, and understandably so.
Circumcision does involve discomfort. Parents deserve an honest answer about that rather than being told that their baby won't feel anything.
At the same time, there are ways to reduce discomfort before, during and after circumcision. The technique I use is extremely brief, and comfort measures are used to help make the experience as easy as possible for the baby.
After the procedure, babies can generally be held, comforted and fed immediately.
When comparing circumcision providers, ask what technique they use and what they do to minimize discomfort. A practitioner should be comfortable explaining the process to you before you make your decision.
9. What If My Baby Didn't Receive the Vitamin K Shot?
Some parents who contact me have chosen not to give their newborn the routine Vitamin K injection and are looking for someone willing to perform the circumcision.
Vitamin K is important for normal blood clotting. Routine newborn Vitamin K is recommended by pediatric organizations because it substantially reduces the risk of Vitamin K deficiency bleeding (VKDB).
I generally do perform circumcisions for babies who have not received the Vitamin K injection. These cases are evaluated individually, and additional precautions may be necessary.
If your baby did not receive Vitamin K, this should always be discussed with the circumcision practitioner before the procedure is scheduled. Parents considering declining Vitamin K should also discuss the benefits and risks with their baby's healthcare provider.
Mohel vs. Doctor for Circumcision: What's the Difference?
Parents sometimes ask whether a mohel or doctor is better for circumcision.
I don't think the decision should be reduced simply to someone's title.
A physician may be an excellent and very experienced circumcision provider. An experienced mohel may likewise have performed a very large number of circumcisions and have extensive procedure-specific experience.
Instead, compare the actual experience you're being offered.
Ask:
How frequently does this person perform circumcisions?
What circumcision technique does the practitioner use?
Who will actually perform my baby's procedure?
How long does the procedure usually take?
What comfort measures are used?
Can I remain with my baby?
Where will the circumcision take place?
Who do I contact if I have a concern afterward?
Is follow-up available if my baby needs to be examined?
For some parents, the hospital or doctor's office will be exactly what they're looking for. Others prefer the specialization, personal relationship, flexibility and direct follow-up available from an experienced mohel.
The important thing is to understand the differences and choose the practitioner and setting with which you feel comfortable.
How Do I Choose a Mohel?
If you've decided to use a mohel, don't be afraid to ask questions before booking.
Ask about training and experience. Find out how long the mohel has been practicing and approximately how frequently he performs circumcisions.
Ask him to explain his technique. Ask what happens before, during and after the procedure. Find out what type of follow-up he provides.
You can also read reviews from previous families and, when available, recommendations from healthcare professionals or others familiar with his work.
Perhaps most importantly, speak to the mohel yourself.
Circumcision is a personal decision involving your newborn son. You should feel comfortable with the person you're entrusting with his care.
Frequently Asked Questions About Using a Mohel
Can a mohel perform a circumcision without a bris?
Yes. Although a mohel is traditionally associated with bris milah, the circumcision itself can be performed without a large ceremony. What is appropriate depends on the family's circumstances and what they are looking for.
Can a mohel perform a circumcision at home?
Yes. Many mohels perform circumcisions in the family's home. I regularly provide home circumcision services for families who prefer the privacy and convenience of having the procedure performed there.
Can a mohel circumcise a non-Jewish baby?
Practices vary from one mohel to another. I do provide circumcision services to families from a variety of backgrounds, including families seeking circumcision for cultural or personal reasons.
How long does a mohel circumcision take?
The length depends on the practitioner and technique. With the technique I use, the actual circumcision generally takes well under a minute, although the full appointment is longer to allow for preparation, examination, questions and aftercare instructions.
What's the difference between a mohel and a doctor for circumcision?
The most important differences can include training, procedure-specific experience, technique, setting and follow-up. A mohel specializes in circumcision and may offer options such as home circumcision and direct access to the practitioner afterward. Individual physicians and mohels vary considerably, so parents should ask about the specific practitioner's experience and approach.
Choosing What's Right for Your Son
There is no reason parents should feel rushed into choosing where or by whom their son's circumcision will be performed.
Ask questions. Understand the technique. Learn about the practitioner's experience. Find out what happens afterward.
For me, being a mohel means much more than performing a procedure. It means taking responsibility for a baby who has been entrusted to my care and being available to his parents before, during and after the circumcision.
After more than 15 years of performing circumcisions, I still consider that personal responsibility one of the most important parts of what I do.
Rabbi Shlomo Golish, C.M. provides newborn circumcision and bris services throughout New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Delaware, including home circumcision for families who prefer to have their baby's circumcision performed in the comfort of their own home.




Comments